[Template] How to Track What Actually Matters in Your Dental Practice
Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) should guide your most important decisions. But they only work when they’re tailored to your unique goals, not pulled from a default dashboard or copied from industry benchmarks that don’t reflect your reality.
Let’s break down how to identify the right KPIs for your dental practice and turn them into tools you can actually use to grow.
Why Custom KPIs Matter
Every dental practice is different. You serve a different patient population, run a different team structure, and have different business goals than the practice down the street—or even the one across town.
That’s why off-the-shelf benchmarks or generic dashboards often fall short. They show you what’s possible. But they don’t show you what’s relevant.
For example:
- A new practice focused on patient growth might track new patient acquisition and phone call conversion rate.
- A multi-location group with full schedules might shift toward metrics like production per visit or hygiene reactivation efficiency.
- A pediatric office may focus more on recall rates and average family value than treatment acceptance percentages.
When you define what success looks like for your team—and then track progress toward that definition—you turn data into action.
Step 1: Start with Your Practice Goals
Before picking KPIs, clarify what you want to accomplish. Not this year. This quarter.
Set specific, measurable goals across different areas of the practice:
- Operations: Reduce missed calls by 30% over the next 90 days.
- Production: Improve same-day treatment acceptance by $10,000 per month.
- Patient Engagement: Increase hygiene reappointment rate to 85%.
These aren’t aspirational dreams. They’re short-term targets you can track and improve. Once your goals are clear, the right KPIs become obvious.
Step 2: Pick 3–5 Core Metrics That Drive Outcomes
There’s a big difference between “interesting” data and “impactful” data. Focus only on KPIs that give you insight and control—numbers that help you identify opportunities and take action quickly.
Here are sample KPIs by category:
Operational Efficiency
- Missed calls per day: How many patients aren’t reaching your team when they call?
- Voicemail volume: Are patients giving up and leaving messages—ones your team might miss?
- Answer rate by time of day: Do you need more coverage at certain hours?
Patient Engagement
- Treatment acceptance rate: How many patients say yes to care?
- Unscheduled treatment value: What’s sitting in the charts, waiting to be rebooked?
- Hygiene reappointment rate: Are you retaining patients or letting them fall off the schedule?
Team Performance
- Call conversion rate: How often do front desk teams turn inbound calls into booked appointments?
- Same-day treatment conversion: Are you maximizing revenue per visit?
- Follow-up lag time: How quickly is your team reaching out after a missed opportunity?
If a number doesn’t tie directly to a decision you can make or an action you can take, it’s probably just noise.
Step 3: Add Context and Trends
Numbers don’t mean much in isolation. Always look at KPIs over time and across teams.
Track each KPI:
- Weekly or monthly to spot patterns
- By provider, team member, or location
- Against benchmarks or internal targets
For example:
If your treatment acceptance rate is 52%, that’s not good or bad on its own. But if it dropped from 60% the month before, and you lost $14,000 in production as a result, now it’s a red flag—and a starting point for action.
You can then dig into causes: Are patients unclear about treatment plans? Is the front desk failing to follow up? Did insurance coverage change?
KPIs should spark curiosity, not just sit on a dashboard.
Step 4: Make KPIs Visible and Shared
You don’t need a high-tech dashboard to make KPIs work. But you do need visibility.
- Post weekly KPIs in your team room or communication platform
- Review them during weekly huddles to create accountability
- Celebrate wins, even small ones, to build momentum
When your team sees what matters—and how their actions contribute to progress—they’re more engaged. More invested. More consistent.
Step 5: Tie KPIs to Action Plans
Tracking is step one. Improvement comes from action.
Every KPI should have a related initiative. If hygiene reappointment is low, your team might:
- Add visual prompts in the treatment room
- Follow up with same-day texts after missed appointments
- Create incentives for patients who book in advance
If your voicemail volume is high, maybe it’s time to:
- Add coverage during peak hours
- Use AI-powered tools to automatically text back missed calls
- Create a backup process for same-day follow-up
KPIs should tell a story. Your job is to write the next chapter.
Bottom Line
Your data can work harder for you, but only if you focus on the right numbers.
When you define success by your own goals and customize your KPIs to reflect them, you make better decisions, coach your team more effectively, and create a more intentional, high-performing practice.
Less noise. More clarity. That’s the power of tracking what matters.
Ready to build out your KPIs and start tracking what really matters? We created a template to get you started.
Use it to discover what performance indicators to track, and to measure and report on progress.
View Similar Blogs
The Rise and Fall of the "All-in-One" Dream
For years, "all-in-one" was the gold standard in dental tech marketing. The pitch was simple: fewer vendors, fewer headaches. One platform to manage your PMS, imaging, analytics, communications, and marketing. It sounded like the perfect solution for overburdened teams and time-starved practice owners.
But here’s the problem: few of those platforms ever did everything well.
We’ve entered a new era. Dental practices—especially those that want to grow—are rejecting bundled platforms in favor of best-in-class solutions. It’s not just a software preference. It’s a strategy shift. It’s about precision, performance, and partnering with experts who do one thing exceptionally well.
Why Unbundling Is Gaining Momentum
Data Point: A 2023 survey by Dental Products Report found that over 67% of private practices plan to switch away from bundled platforms in the next 12–18 months, citing customization, speed of innovation, and user experience as top reasons.
Another stat worth noting: In Peerlogic's own client data, practices that moved away from legacy all-in-one platforms and adopted specialized tech saw a 23% increase in operational efficiency within the first 60 days.
1. Bundled systems mean compromise.
All-in-one platforms promise convenience, but that often comes at the cost of functionality. When your imaging is decent, your analytics are basic, and your call tracking is barely usable, your practice ends up working around the tech instead of being powered by it.
2. Innovation moves faster in focused companies.
When a vendor is trying to be everything to everyone, innovation slows down. Compare that to niche platforms with tight focus: they update faster, adapt better, and drive real change in the part of your business they support.
3. Integration isn’t the enemy anymore.
A decade ago, integrations were painful. Today, modern APIs, middleware, and cloud-based systems mean the right stack doesn’t just work—it flows. Data is more visible, more actionable, and more aligned across systems.
4. DSOs and private practices need adaptability.
Your needs evolve. You scale. You acquire. You launch a specialty. With a modular, unbundled stack, you can swap out components as your business shifts—without a total overhaul.
What This Looks Like in Practice
Let’s break it down by capability:
- Call intelligence and missed call recovery
- Marketing analytics
- Practice management systems (PMS)
- Clinical imaging and diagnostics
- Patient communications and engagement
Each layer of the tech stack is specialized, intentionally selected, and strategically implemented.
When you stop looking for one vendor to solve everything, you start building a system that performs better across the board. Your front office gets better tools. Your ops team gets cleaner data. Your patients get a better experience.
When you stop looking for one vendor to solve everything, you start building a tech stack that performs better across the board. Your front office gets better tools. Your ops team gets cleaner data. Your patients get a better experience.
The Doctor-Partner Dynamic Is Changing
There’s a bigger cultural shift happening, too.
Doctors don’t want to be tech buyers. They want to be clinical leaders. They want to focus on delivering care—not troubleshooting platforms or making do with a mediocre feature set.
The most successful practice leaders today aren’t trying to be experts in marketing analytics or AI call automation. They’re partnering with companies that already are.
They’re hiring fractional COOs. Investing in ops leads. Collaborating with tech partners that actually show them the data and work to improve outcomes. This is what modern leadership looks like in dental.
DSOs Are Leading the Charge
DSOs have seen this movie before. They know the cost of inefficiency. They’ve lived through platform lock-in. They’ve built acquisition strategies around agility.
Which is why the savviest DSOs are prioritizing:
- Interoperability across systems
- Real-time visibility into performance metrics
- Conversion tracking tied to marketing spend
- Vendor relationships based on outcomes, not checklists
They’re not afraid to fire a partner that underperforms. And they’re not afraid to pay more for tools that drive measurable ROI. That mindset is now trickling down to midsize groups and even solo practices.
What You Risk by Staying Bundled
- Limited customization: You’re stuck with the way the platform works, even if it doesn’t match your workflow.
- Slower innovation: You wait months (or years) for updates while niche players are shipping new features quarterly.
- Data silos: Ironically, all-in-one tools often hide data behind clunky dashboards or limited export capabilities.
- Support gaps: When everything is bundled, support is broad but shallow. You don’t get the depth you need to solve complex issues.
Not All Vendors Are Trying to Be All-in-One
At Peerlogic, we’re intentionally not an all-in-one platform. We focus on three powerful, interconnected capabilities: VoIP, analytics, and AI.
- VoIP: Streamlined, reliable call infrastructure built for healthcare
- Analytics: Actionable call and conversion insights that drive smarter decisions
- AI (Aimee): Real-time follow-up and patient recovery that supports, not replaces, your staff
We don’t do digital forms. We don’t process payments. We don’t offer watered-down tools that sound good in a demo but get ignored in real workflows.
Instead, we build tech that plays well with others and delivers fast ROI in the areas that matter most.
That’s the unbundled mindset. That’s how modern practices win.
The era of “all-in-one” is fading fast. The future is modular, measurable, and built around expert partners who do what they do best.
Unbundling isn’t about making your life more complicated. It’s about making your tools work for you—not the other way around.
And for practices that want to grow, scale, and compete? That’s not optional. That’s table stakes.
Here’s how to take stock—using the tools you already have—and set your practice up for a stronger second half of the year.
1. Start With the Data You Already Have
Most practices are sitting on a goldmine of insights—they just don’t realize it. Here’s where to look:
Google Analytics (GA4)
- Check your top pages. Is your “Book Now” link easy to find and use on mobile?
- Review traffic sources. Where are new patients coming from?
- Identify drop-off points. Are patients bouncing before they contact you?
Call Logs + Voicemail Reports
- Pull two weeks of call data. Look at missed calls by time of day and day of week.
- Flag repeat voicemails or abandoned calls—those are often lost opportunities.
- Check response time. Are callbacks happening quickly?
Google Business Profile Insights
- See how many people are clicking to call, get directions, or visit your site.
- Review and update business hours, service offerings, and photos.
- Make sure you’re ranking for the services you actually want to be known for.
Scheduling Software Reports
- Look at average time to next available appointment.
- Review no-show and cancellation rates.
- Check for gaps in the schedule—especially during peak demand times.
Email Platform Metrics
- Track open/click rates for patient reminders or newsletters.
- See which topics patients engage with most.
- Unsubscribes can reveal where your communication strategy needs refinement.
2. Evaluate Key Operational Pressure Points
Once you’ve checked your core tools, zoom out and take a broader look at what’s working—and what needs attention.
Automate Missed Call Follow-Ups
You will miss calls. The question is: do they call back—or someone else?
Action Items:
- Use a tool like Aimee to automatically text back missed calls in real time.
- Connect it to your scheduler so patients can book immediately.
- Track how many appointments are recovered this way.
Bonus: This lightens the load for your front desk while filling your calendar.
Cross-Train for Flexibility
If only one person can reschedule patients or check voicemails, you’re one absence away from chaos.
Action Items:
- Train multiple team members on key front desk workflows.
- Document how-to’s for voicemail, scheduling, and insurance verifications.
- Create a shared knowledge base for temp or floating staff to access anytime.
Prep Scripts for Repeat Summer Questions
Vacation season = the same patient questions, over and over.
Action Items:
- Write ready-to-use responses for FAQs like:
- “Do you have anything before school starts?”
- “Are you open on July 4th?”
- “What if I need to cancel last-minute?”
- Store scripts where your team communicates (Slack, front desk binder, EHR notes).
- Review and refresh these every season.
3. Go Deeper: Evaluate These 7 Strategic Metrics
Want to lead your practice like an operations pro? These are the areas to review at least twice a year:
1. Patient Experience Touchpoints
- Call tone and on-hold message
- Text/email timing and tone
- In-office check-in and follow-up flow
2. No-Show and Cancellation Protocols
- Current no-show rate
- Reminder timing and channels
- Waitlist rebooking speed
3. Call Handling Consistency
- Intake script usage
- Conversion rates per rep or location
- Escalation process for tough calls
4. Revenue Per Appointment Type
- Compare revenue vs. time spent
- Identify low-ROI services
- Plan staffing around high-value visits
5. Staff Workload + Burnout Risk
- Calls handled per shift
- Daily leftover tasks
- PTO usage vs. availability
6. Marketing ROI and Lead Conversion
- Cost per booked appointment
- Conversion by lead source
- Follow-up effectiveness
7. Tech Stack Efficiency
- Manual double entry across platforms
- Unused or underutilized tools
- Integration gaps that slow your team down
Summer is your built-in checkpoint. You don’t need to slow down, but you should look up.
You’ve already got the tools. Now it’s time to use them to drive clarity, reduce chaos, and create momentum that lasts into the fall.
Need help turning data into action?
Book a quick demo and we’ll show you how Peerlogic helps practices recover missed calls, fill schedules, and unlock insights—without piling on more work.
AI has earned its place in patient operations, especially when it comes to speed, consistency, and capturing the opportunities busy teams miss.
At Peerlogic, we’ve seen firsthand how AI can support the front office by recovering revenue, reducing staff burnout, and ensuring patients don’t fall through the cracks.
But we've also found this to be true: AI works best when it’s part of a broader strategy. One that values human oversight, and protects the patient experience. One that doesn’t stop at automation, but uses it to enhance relationships, not replace them.
Because in healthcare, speed without empathy isn’t service. It’s just noise.
AI is everywhere. Especially in patient communications.
But too many vendors are flooding the space with plug-and-play voice bots that miss the mark on one critical thing: the patient experience.
Because automation without intentionality doesn’t feel helpful. It feels hollow.
The Evidence Is Mounting: People Still Want People
A 2024 Fast Company survey found that customer satisfaction drops by over 30% when AI-only tools handle service interactions.
NICE’s benchmark report shows:
- 74% of healthcare patients value timely, personalized communication above all else
- 52% would leave a provider for better engagement
- The average response time across practices? Still lags well beyond what patients expect
AI may solve for speed—but without a human layer, it doesn’t solve for trust.
What Patients Actually Want
Let’s be clear: Patients aren’t anti-AI. They’re anti-bad experiences.
They want:
- To feel heard, not just responded to
- A follow-up that’s tailored, not templated
- Speed and accuracy
They’re fine talking to an AI—as long as it’s helpful, empathetic, and smart enough to know when to loop in a human.
The Real Issue: AI Without Oversight
Too many AI tools are being deployed without:
- Human review
- Healthcare-specific training
- Alignment with real workflows
What happens?
- Missed context
- Robotic interactions
- Frustrated patients
- Lost opportunities
That’s the risk when vendors promise AI as a replacement, not a reinforcement.
At Peerlogic, we think of AI differently.
We don’t believe AI should replace your front office.
We believe AI should catch what your team can’t. And make their jobs easier—not irrelevant.
Aimee (our AI) is designed to:
- Follow up on missed calls instantly
- Reference the original patient voicemail or context
- Log outcomes clearly in your dashboard
- And hand it off when nuance or clinical info is required
It’s not AI-only. It’s AI + your team, working in sync.
Why This Matters Now
Case in Point: The Power of Training + AI
In a recent collaboration with the Scheduling Institute, we helped practices see what happens when AI recovery meets trained, motivated teams. By aligning follow-up workflows with top-tier training, practices saw faster patient reactivation, better call handling, and real revenue impact.
The takeaway? Tools matter. But people matter more. Combine them, and you unlock the best of both worlds.
With staffing challenges continuing, practices are desperate for relief. But the answer isn’t to automate at all costs.
The answer is to automate strategically. To preserve quality while gaining speed. To reduce burden without losing connection.
In a space where every patient touchpoint matters, speed + empathy is the new gold standard.
AI is here to stay. But the future isn’t artificial vs. human. It’s both.
The practices that win will be the ones that build hybrid systems: smart, responsive, and deeply human.
At Peerlogic, we’re not just building AI. We’re building trust.
Want to see how? Book a quick walkthrough and get to know our patient-centered AI, Aimee. We promise: it feels different.
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
